I like the basic idea, although I'm not sure about the "star" system. In my opinion, there's absolutely nothing wrong with a theme which you describe as having 1 star: a solid, entry-level theme, built and tested to agreed standards, using accepted practices. Being a "1 star" might imply to some that the theme may be dysfunctional, one that should be avoided.
I can't imagine a theme author marketing their theme who would say something like "yeah, this is a certified 1 star theme." Even though it may a perfectly functional, solid theme, if I was just a beginner, I would imagine being turned off by this "1 star" label.
Instead of stars, maybe there could be word labels such as: solid, flexible, advanced, things like that. Just a thought.
|